1989 Paper 1 Q1

Year: 1989
Paper: 1
Question Number: 1

Course: LFM Pure
Section: Coordinate Geometry

Difficulty: 1500.0 Banger: 1500.0

Problem

TikZ diagram
In the above diagram, \(ABC,CDE,EFG\) and \(AHG\) are semicircles and \(A,C,E,G\) lie on a straight line. The radii of \(ABC,EFG,AHG\) are \(h\), \(h\) and \(r\) respectively, where \(2h < r\). Show that the area enclosed by \(ABCDEFGH\) is equal to that of a circle with diameter \(HD\). Each semicircle is now replaced by a portion of a parabola, with vertex at the midpoint of the semicircle arc, passing through the endpoints (so, for example, \(ABC\) is replaced by part of a parabola passing through \(A\) and \(C\) and with vertex at \(B\)). Find a formula in terms of \(r\) and \(h\) for the area enclosed by \(ABCDEFGH\).

Solution

\(AG = r\), therefore the area is: \begin{align*} A &= [AHG] - 2*[ABC] + [CDE] \\ &= \frac12 \pi r^2 - \pi h^2 + \frac12 \pi (r-2h)^2 \\ &= \frac12 \pi \l r^2 - 2h^2 + r^2 -4rh+4h^2 \r \\ &= \frac12 \pi \l 2r^2 -4rh + 2h^2\r \\ &= \pi (r-h)^2 \end{align*} This is the same area as a circle radius \(r-h\) But \(HD = r + (r-2d) = 2(r-d)\), ie the circle with diameter \(HD\) has radius \(r-h\) as required. Suppose \(A = (-h, 0), C = (h, 0), B = (0, h)\) then our parabola is \(y = \frac1{h}(h^2-x^2)\)
TikZ diagram
The area of \(ABC\) would then be \(\int_{-h}^h \frac{1}{h}(h^2-x^2) \d x = \frac1{h} \left [ h^2x - \frac{x^3}{3} \right] = \frac1{h} \l 2h^3-2\frac{h^3}{3} \r = \frac{4}{3}h^2\) so we have: \begin{align*} A &= [AHG] - 2*[ABC] +[CDE] \\ &= \frac43 r^2-\frac83h^2+\frac43(r-2h)^2 \\ &= \frac43 \l r^2 -2h^2+r^2-4rh+4h^2) \\ &= \frac43 (r-h)^2 \end{align*}
Rating Information

Difficulty Rating: 1500.0

Difficulty Comparisons: 0

Banger Rating: 1500.0

Banger Comparisons: 0

Show LaTeX source
Problem source
\begin{center}
    \begin{tikzpicture}[scale = 3]
        \draw[domain = 0:180, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({1.5*cos(\x)},{1.5*sin(\x)});
        \draw[domain = 180:360, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({0.5*cos(\x)},{0.5*sin(\x)});
        \draw[domain = 0:180, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({0.5*cos(\x)-1},{0.5*sin(\x)});
        \draw[domain = 0:180, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({0.5*cos(\x)+1},{0.5*sin(\x)});
        \node at (-1.5, 0) [below left] {$A$};
        \node at (1.5, 0) [below right] {$G$};
        \node at (0, -.5) [below] {$D$};
        \node at (-0.5, 0) [left] {$C$};
        \node at (0.5, 0) [right] {$E$};
        \node at (1, 0.5) [above] {$F$};
        \node at (-1, 0.5) [above] {$B$};
        \node at (0, 1.5) [above] {$H$};
    \end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}
In the above diagram, $ABC,CDE,EFG$ and $AHG$ are semicircles and $A,C,E,G$ lie on a straight line. The radii of $ABC,EFG,AHG$ are $h$, $h$ and $r$ respectively, where $2h < r$. Show that the area enclosed by $ABCDEFGH$ is equal to that of a circle with diameter $HD$. 
Each semicircle is now replaced by a portion of a parabola, with vertex at the midpoint of the semicircle arc, passing through the endpoints (so, for example, $ABC$ is replaced by part of a parabola passing through $A$ and $C$ and with vertex at $B$). Find a formula in terms of $r$ and $h$ for the area enclosed by $ABCDEFGH$.
Solution source
$AG = r$, therefore the area is:

\begin{align*}
A &= [AHG] - 2*[ABC] + [CDE] \\
&= \frac12 \pi r^2 - \pi h^2 + \frac12 \pi (r-2h)^2 \\
&= \frac12 \pi \l r^2 - 2h^2 + r^2 -4rh+4h^2  \r \\
&= \frac12 \pi \l 2r^2 -4rh + 2h^2\r \\
&= \pi (r-h)^2
\end{align*}

This is the same area as a circle radius $r-h$

But $HD = r + (r-2d)  = 2(r-d)$, ie the circle with diameter $HD$ has radius $r-h$ as required.

Suppose $A = (-h, 0), C = (h, 0), B = (0, h)$ then our parabola is $y = \frac1{h}(h^2-x^2)$

\begin{center}
    \begin{tikzpicture}[scale = 3]
        \draw[domain = 0:180, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({1.5*cos(\x)},{1.5*sin(\x)});
        \draw[domain = 180:360, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({0.5*cos(\x)},{0.5*sin(\x)});
        \draw[domain = 0:180, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({0.5*cos(\x)-1},{0.5*sin(\x)});
        \draw[domain = 0:180, samples=50, variable = \x]  plot ({0.5*cos(\x)+1},{0.5*sin(\x)});

        \node at (-1.5, 0) [below left] {$A$};
        \node at (1.5, 0) [below right] {$G$};
        \node at (0, -.5) [below] {$D$};
        \node at (-0.5, 0) [left] {$C$};
        \node at (0.5, 0) [right] {$E$};
        \node at (1, 0.5) [above] {$F$};
        \node at (-1, 0.5) [above] {$B$};
        \node at (0, 1.5) [above] {$H$};


        \draw[domain = -1.5:1.5, samples=50, variable = \x, red]  plot ({\x},{1/1.5 * ( 1.5^2 - (\x)^2)});
        \draw[domain = -0.5:0.5, samples=50, variable = \x, red]  plot ({\x},{-1/0.5 * ( 0.5^2 - (\x)^2)});
        \draw[domain = -0.5:0.5, samples=50, variable = \x, red]  plot ({\x-1},{1/0.5 * ( 0.5^2 - (\x)^2)});
        \draw[domain = -0.5:0.5, samples=50, variable = \x, red]  plot ({\x+1},{1/0.5 * ( 0.5^2 - (\x)^2)});
    \end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}

The area of $ABC$ would then be $\int_{-h}^h \frac{1}{h}(h^2-x^2) \d x = \frac1{h} \left [ h^2x - \frac{x^3}{3} \right] = \frac1{h} \l 2h^3-2\frac{h^3}{3} \r = \frac{4}{3}h^2$

so we have:

\begin{align*}
A &= [AHG] - 2*[ABC] +[CDE] \\
&= \frac43 r^2-\frac83h^2+\frac43(r-2h)^2 \\
&= \frac43 \l r^2 -2h^2+r^2-4rh+4h^2) \\
&= \frac43 (r-h)^2
\end{align*}