2017 Paper 1 Q6

Year: 2017
Paper: 1
Question Number: 6

Course: LFM Pure and Mechanics
Section: Integration as Area

Difficulty: 1516.0 Banger: 1484.0

Problem

In this question, you may assume that, if a continuous function takes both positive and negative values in an interval, then it takes the value \(0\) at some point in that interval.
  1. The function \(\f\) is continuous and \(\f(x)\) is non-zero for some value of \(x\) in the interval \(0\le x \le 1\). Prove by contradiction, or otherwise, that if \[ \int_0^1 \f(x) \d x = 0\,, \] then \(\f(x)\) takes both positive and negative values in the interval \(0\le x\le 1\).
  2. The function \(\g\) is continuous and \[ \int_0^1 \g(x) \, \d x = 1\,, \quad \int_0^1 x\g(x) \, \d x = \alpha\, , \quad \int_0^1 x^2\g(x) \, \d x = \alpha^2\,. \tag{\(*\)} \] Show, by considering \[ \int_0^1 (x - \alpha)^2 \g(x) \, \d x \,, \] that \(\g(x)=0\) for some value of \(x\) in the interval \(0\le x\le 1\). Find a function of the form \(\g(x) = a+bx\) that satisfies the conditions \((*)\) and verify that \(\g(x)=0\) for some value of \(x\) in the interval \(0\le x \le 1\).
  3. The function \(\h\) has a continuous derivative \(\h'\) and \[ \h(0) = 0\,, \quad \h(1) = 1\,, \quad \int_0^1 \h(x) \, \d x = \beta\,, \quad \int_0^1 x \h(x) \, \d x = \tfrac{1}{2}\beta (2 - \beta) \,. \] Use the result in part (ii) to show that \(\h^\prime(x)=0\) for some value of \(x\) in the interval \(0\le x\le 1\).

Solution

  1. Claim: If \(f(x)\) non-zero for some \(x \in [0,1]\) and \(\int_0^1 f(x) \d x =0\) then \(f\) takes both positive and negative values in the interval \([0,1]\). Proof: Suppose not, then WLOG suppose \(f(x) > 0\) for some \(x \in [0,1]\). Then notice (since \(f\) is continuous) that there is some interval where \(f(x) > 0\) around the \(x\) we have already shown exists. But then \(\int_{\text{interval}} f(x) \d x > 0\) and since \(f(x) \geq 0\) everywhere \(\int_0^1 f(x) \d x > 0\), which is a contradiction.
  2. \(\,\) \begin{align*} && \int_0^1 (x - \alpha)^2 g(x) \d x &= \int_0^1 x^2g(x) \d x - 2 \alpha \int_0^1 x g(x) \d x + \alpha^2 \int_0^1 g(x) \d x \\ &&&= \alpha^2 - 2\alpha \cdot \alpha + \alpha^2 \cdot 1 \\ &&&= 0 \end{align*} Therefore \(g(x)(x-\alpha)^2\) is a continuous function which is either exactly \(0\) (in which case we've already found our \(0\)) or it is a continuous function which is both positive somewhere and has \(0\) integral, and therefore by part (i) must take both positive and negative values (and therefore takes \(0\) in between those points by continuity). \begin{align*} &&1 &= \int_0^1 a+bx \d x \\ &&&= a + \frac12 b \\ && \alpha &= \int_0^1 ax + bx^2 \d x \\ &&&= \frac12 a + \frac13 b \\ && \alpha^2 &= \int_0^1 ax^2 + bx^3 \d x\\ &&&= \frac13 a + \frac14 b \\ \Rightarrow && \frac1{36}(3a+2b)^2 &= \frac1{12}(4a+3b) \\ \Rightarrow && \frac1{36}(3a+2(2-2a))^2 &= \frac1{12}(4a+3(2-2a)) \\ \Rightarrow && (4-a)^2 &= 3(6-2a) \\ \Rightarrow && 16-8a+a^2 &= 18-6a \\ \Rightarrow && a^2-2a-2 &= 0 \\ \Rightarrow && (a-1)^2 - 3 &= 0 \\ \Rightarrow && a &= \pm \sqrt{3}+1 \\ && b &= \mp 2\sqrt{3} \end{align*} So say \(a = \sqrt{3}+1, b = -2\sqrt{3}\) This has a root at \(-\frac{a}{b} = \frac{1+\sqrt{3}}{2\sqrt{3}} = \frac{\sqrt{3}+3}{6} < 1\) so we have met our condition.
  3. Consider \(h'\), we must have \begin{align*} && \int_0^1 h'(x)\d x &= h(1)-h(0) =1\\ && \int_0^1 xh'(x) \d x &= \left [x h(x) \right]_0^1 - \int_0^1 h(x) \d x \\ &&&= 1 - \beta \\ && \int_0^1 x^2 h'(x) \d x &= \left [ x^2h(x) \right]_0^1 - \int_0^1 2xh(x) \d x \\ &&&= 1 - 2\tfrac12 \beta(2-\beta) \\ &&&= (1-\beta)^2 \end{align*} Therefore \(h'\) satisfies the conditions with \(\alpha = 1-\beta\), so \(h'\) must have a root in our interval.
Examiner's report
— 2017 STEP 1, Question 6
Below Average Fewest attempts among pure questions; quite low average mark

This question received the smallest number of attempts of all of the pure questions on the paper, a significant proportion of which did not go beyond an attempt to prove the first result before abandoning the question. The average mark for the question was therefore quite low. There were however a number of good responses to the question. The proof by contradiction in the first part often received a partial explanation. Where the link between parts (i) and (ii) was seen candidates were often able to make good progress on the second part, although some errors in calculation occasionally led to incorrect examples of the function required. Part (iii) required more care to work through successfully and only a small proportion of the candidates were able to see how to apply the previous result and then complete this part successfully.

The pure questions were again the most popular of the paper with questions 1 and 3 being attempted by almost all candidates. The least popular questions on the paper were questions 10, 11, 12 and 13 and a significant proportion of attempts at these were brief, attracting few or no marks. Candidates generally demonstrated a high level of competence when completing the standard processes and there were many good attempts made when questions required explanations to be given, particularly within the pure questions. A common feature of the stronger responses to questions was the inclusion of diagrams.

Source: Cambridge STEP 2017 Examiner's Report · 2017-full.pdf
Rating Information

Difficulty Rating: 1516.0

Difficulty Comparisons: 1

Banger Rating: 1484.0

Banger Comparisons: 1

Show LaTeX source
Problem source
In this question, you may assume that, if a continuous  function 
takes both positive and negative values in an interval, then
it takes the value $0$ at some point in that interval. 
\begin{questionparts}
\item
The function  $\f$ is continuous and $\f(x)$ is non-zero for some value 
of $x$ in the interval $0\le x \le 1$. Prove by contradiction, or otherwise,
 that if
\[
\int_0^1 \f(x) \d x = 0\,,
\]
then 
 $\f(x)$ takes both positive and negative values 
in the interval $0\le x\le 1$.
\item The function  $\g$ is continuous and
\[
\int_0^1 \g(x) \, \d x = 1\,,
 \quad 
\int_0^1 x\g(x) \, \d x = \alpha\, , 
\quad 
\int_0^1 x^2\g(x) \, \d x = \alpha^2\,.
\tag{$*$}
\] 
 Show, by considering
\[
\int_0^1 (x - \alpha)^2 \g(x) \, \d x
\,,
\]
 that
$\g(x)=0$ for some value of $x$ in the interval $0\le x\le 1$.
Find a function of the  form $\g(x) = a+bx$ that satisfies the conditions
$(*)$ and verify that $\g(x)=0$ for some value of $x$ in the interval 
$0\le x \le 1$.
\item
The function $\h$ has a continuous derivative $\h'$ and
\[
\h(0) = 0\,,
\quad 
\h(1) = 1\,,
\quad 
\int_0^1 \h(x) \, \d x = \beta\,, 
\quad 
\int_0^1 x \h(x) \, \d x = \tfrac{1}{2}\beta (2 - \beta)
\,.
\] 
Use the result in part (ii) to show that $\h^\prime(x)=0$ 
for some value of $x$ in the interval $0\le x\le 1$.
\end{questionparts}
Solution source
\begin{questionparts}
\item Claim: If $f(x)$ non-zero for some $x \in [0,1]$ and $\int_0^1 f(x) \d x =0$ then $f$ takes both positive and negative values in the interval $[0,1]$.

Proof: Suppose not, then WLOG suppose $f(x) > 0$ for some $x \in [0,1]$. Then notice (since $f$ is continuous) that there is some interval where $f(x) > 0$ around the $x$ we have already shown exists. But then $\int_{\text{interval}} f(x) \d x > 0$ and since $f(x) \geq 0$ everywhere $\int_0^1 f(x) \d x > 0$, which is a contradiction.

\item $\,$ \begin{align*}
&& \int_0^1 (x - \alpha)^2 g(x) \d x &= \int_0^1 x^2g(x) \d x - 2 \alpha \int_0^1 x g(x) \d x + \alpha^2 \int_0^1 g(x) \d x \\
&&&= \alpha^2 - 2\alpha \cdot \alpha + \alpha^2 \cdot 1 \\
&&&= 0
\end{align*} Therefore $g(x)(x-\alpha)^2$ is a continuous function which is either exactly $0$ (in which case we've already found our $0$) or it is a continuous function which is both positive somewhere and has $0$ integral, and therefore by part (i) must take both positive and negative values (and therefore takes $0$ in between those points by continuity).

\begin{align*}
&&1 &= \int_0^1 a+bx \d x \\
&&&= a + \frac12 b \\
&& \alpha &= \int_0^1 ax + bx^2 \d x \\
&&&= \frac12 a + \frac13 b \\
&& \alpha^2 &= \int_0^1 ax^2 + bx^3 \d x\\
&&&= \frac13 a + \frac14 b \\ 
\Rightarrow && \frac1{36}(3a+2b)^2 &= \frac1{12}(4a+3b) \\
\Rightarrow && \frac1{36}(3a+2(2-2a))^2 &= \frac1{12}(4a+3(2-2a)) \\
\Rightarrow && (4-a)^2 &= 3(6-2a) \\
\Rightarrow && 16-8a+a^2 &= 18-6a \\
\Rightarrow && a^2-2a-2 &= 0 \\
\Rightarrow && (a-1)^2 - 3 &= 0 \\
\Rightarrow && a &= \pm \sqrt{3}+1 \\
&& b &= \mp 2\sqrt{3}
\end{align*}

So say $a = \sqrt{3}+1, b = -2\sqrt{3}$

This has a root at $-\frac{a}{b} = \frac{1+\sqrt{3}}{2\sqrt{3}} = \frac{\sqrt{3}+3}{6} < 1$ so we have met our condition.

\item Consider $h'$, we must have

\begin{align*}
&& \int_0^1 h'(x)\d x &= h(1)-h(0) =1\\
&& \int_0^1 xh'(x) \d x &= \left [x h(x) \right]_0^1 - \int_0^1 h(x) \d x \\
&&&= 1 - \beta \\
&& \int_0^1 x^2 h'(x) \d x &= \left [ x^2h(x) \right]_0^1 - \int_0^1 2xh(x) \d x \\
&&&= 1 - 2\tfrac12 \beta(2-\beta) \\
&&&= (1-\beta)^2
\end{align*}

Therefore $h'$ satisfies the conditions with $\alpha = 1-\beta$, so $h'$ must have a root in our interval.
\end{questionparts}