1999 Paper 3 Q4

Year: 1999
Paper: 3
Question Number: 4

Course: LFM Pure
Section: Proof

Difficulty: 1700.0 Banger: 1516.0

Problem

A polyhedron is a solid bounded by \(F\) plane faces, which meet in \(E\) edges and \(V\) vertices. You may assume \textit{Euler's formula}, that \(V-E+F=2\). In a regular polyhedron the faces are equal regular \(m\)-sided polygons, \(n\) of which meet at each vertex. Show that $$ F={4n\over h} \,, $$ where \(h=4-(n-2)(m-2)\). By considering the possible values of \(h\), or otherwise, prove that there are only five regular polyhedra, and find \(V\), \(E\) and \(F\) for each.

Solution

Note that each of the \(F\) faces have \(m\) edges. If we count edges from each face we will get \(mF\) edges, but this counts each edge twice, so \(E = \frac{m}{2}F\). Similarly each edge goes into \(2\) vertices, but this counts each vertex \(n\) times, therefore \(V = \frac{2E}{n} = \frac{m}{n}F\) Therefore \begin{align*} && 2 &= V - E + F \\ &&&= \frac{m}{n}F - \frac{m}{2}F + F \\ &&&= F \left ( \frac{2m-nm+2n}{2n} \right) \\ &&&= F \left ( \frac{4-(n-2)(m-2)}{2n} \right) \\ \Rightarrow && F &= \frac{4n}{4-(n-2)(m-2)} = \frac{4n}{h} \end{align*} Notice that \(1 \leq h \leq 4\), so If \(h = 4\), then \(n = 2\) or \(m = 2\) but we can't have two-sided polygons or polyhedra with two faces making a vertex so this is not possible. If \(h = 3\) then \((n-2)(m-2) = 1\) and \(3 \mid n\), so we have \(n = 3, m = 3\). ie we have triangular faces meeting at \(3\) per point. We also have \(F = \frac{4 \cdot 3 }3\) which is \(4\) faces so this is a tetrahedron and \((V,E, F) = (4, 6, 4)\) If \(h = 2\) then \((n-2)(m-2) = 2\): Case 1: \(n = 4, m = 3\) which is four triangles meeting at each vertex with \((V,E,F) = (6, 12, 8)\), ie an octohedron. Case 2: \(n = 3, m = 4\) so we have three squares meeting at each vertex, with \((V,E,F) = (8,12,6)\) which is a cube. If \(h = 1\) then \((n-2)(m-2) = 3\) Case 1: \(n = 5, m = 3\) which is five triangles meeting at each vertex, with \((V,E,F) = ( 12,30, 20)\) ie an icosahedron. Case 2: \(n = 3, m = 5\) which is three pentagons meeting at each vertex, with \((V,E,F) = (20, 30,12)\) which is a dodecahedron. These are all the possible cases and hence we have found the five platonic solids.
Rating Information

Difficulty Rating: 1700.0

Difficulty Comparisons: 0

Banger Rating: 1516.0

Banger Comparisons: 1

Show LaTeX source
Problem source
A polyhedron is a solid bounded by $F$ plane faces, which meet in $E$ edges and $V$ vertices. You may assume \textit{Euler's
formula}, that $V-E+F=2$.
In a regular polyhedron the faces are equal regular $m$-sided
polygons, $n$ of which meet at each vertex. Show that
$$
F={4n\over h}  \,,
$$
where $h=4-(n-2)(m-2)$.
By considering the possible values of $h$, or otherwise, prove that there are only five regular polyhedra, and find $V$, $E$ and $F$ for each.
Solution source
Note that each of the $F$ faces have $m$ edges. If we count edges from each face we will get $mF$ edges, but this counts each edge twice, so $E = \frac{m}{2}F$. Similarly each edge goes into $2$ vertices, but this counts each vertex $n$ times, therefore $V = \frac{2E}{n} = \frac{m}{n}F$

Therefore \begin{align*}
&& 2 &= V - E + F \\
&&&= \frac{m}{n}F - \frac{m}{2}F + F \\
&&&= F \left ( \frac{2m-nm+2n}{2n} \right) \\
&&&= F \left ( \frac{4-(n-2)(m-2)}{2n} \right) \\
\Rightarrow && F &= \frac{4n}{4-(n-2)(m-2)} = \frac{4n}{h}
\end{align*}

Notice that $1 \leq h \leq 4$, so

If $h = 4$, then $n = 2$ or $m = 2$ but we can't have two-sided polygons or polyhedra with two faces making a vertex so this is not possible.

If $h = 3$ then $(n-2)(m-2) = 1$ and $3 \mid n$, so we have $n = 3, m = 3$. ie we have triangular faces meeting at $3$ per point. We also have $F = \frac{4 \cdot 3 }3$ which is $4$ faces so this is a tetrahedron and $(V,E, F) = (4, 6, 4)$

If $h = 2$ then $(n-2)(m-2) = 2$:
Case 1: $n = 4, m = 3$ which is four triangles meeting at each vertex with $(V,E,F) = (6, 12, 8)$, ie an octohedron.
Case 2: $n = 3, m = 4$ so we have three squares meeting at each vertex, with $(V,E,F) = (8,12,6)$ which is a cube.

If $h = 1$ then $(n-2)(m-2) = 3$
Case 1: $n = 5, m = 3$ which is five triangles meeting at each vertex, with $(V,E,F) = ( 12,30, 20)$ ie an icosahedron.
Case 2: $n = 3, m = 5$ which is three pentagons meeting at each vertex, with $(V,E,F) = (20, 30,12)$ which is a dodecahedron.

These are all the possible cases and hence we have found the five platonic solids.