2018 Paper 3 Q11

Year: 2018
Paper: 3
Question Number: 11

Course: UFM Mechanics
Section: Circular Motion 2

Difficulty: 1700.0 Banger: 1487.9

Problem

A particle is attached to one end of a light inextensible string of length \(b\). The other end of the string is attached to a fixed point \(O\). Initially the particle hangs vertically below \(O\). The particle then receives a horizontal impulse. The particle moves in a circular arc with the string taut until the acute angle between the string and the upward vertical is \(\alpha\), at which time it becomes slack. Express \(V\), the speed of the particle when the string becomes slack, in terms of \( b\), \(g\) and \(\alpha\). Show that the string becomes taut again a time \(T\) later, where \[ gT = 4V \sin\alpha \,,\] and that just before this time the trajectory of the particle makes an angle \(\beta \) with the horizontal where \(\tan\beta = 3\tan \alpha \,\). When the string becomes taut, the momentum of the particle in the direction of the string is destroyed. Show that the particle comes instantaneously to rest at this time if and only if \[ \sin^2\alpha = \dfrac {1+\sqrt3}4 \,. \]

Solution

TikZ diagram
\begin{align*} \text{N2}(\swarrow): &&T +mg \cos \alpha &= m \frac{V^2}{b} \\ \end{align*} So the string goes slack when \(bg\cos \alpha = V^2 \Rightarrow V = \sqrt{bg \cos \alpha}\). Once the string goes slack, the particle moves as a projectile. It's initial speed is \(V\binom{-\cos \alpha}{\sin \alpha}\) and it's position is \(\binom{b\sin \alpha}{b\cos \alpha}\): \begin{align*} && \mathbf{s} &= \binom{b\sin \alpha}{b\cos \alpha}+Vt \binom{-\cos \alpha}{\sin \alpha} + \frac12 gt^2 \binom{0}{-1} \\ &&&= \binom{b\sin \alpha - Vt \cos \alpha}{b\cos \alpha + Vt \sin \alpha - \frac12 gt^2} \\ |\mathbf{s}|^2 = b^2 \Rightarrow && b^2 &= \left ( \binom{b\sin \alpha}{b\cos \alpha}+Vt \binom{-\cos \alpha}{\sin \alpha} + \frac12 gt^2 \binom{0}{-1} \right)^2 \\ &&&= b^2 + V^2t^2+\frac14 g^2 t^4 -gb\cos \alpha t^2-V\sin \alpha gt^3 \\ \Rightarrow && 0 &= V^2t^2 + \frac14 g^2 t^4 - V^2 t^2- V \sin \alpha g t^3 \\ &&&= \frac14 g^2 t^4 - V \sin \alpha gt^3 \\ \Rightarrow && gT &= 4V \sin \alpha \end{align*} The particle will have velocity \(\displaystyle \binom{-V \cos \alpha}{V \sin \alpha - 4V \sin \alpha} = \binom{-V \cos \alpha}{-3V \sin \alpha}\) so the angle \(\beta\) will satisfy \(\tan \beta = 3 \tan \alpha\). The particle will come to an instantaneous rest if all the momentum is destroyed, ie if the particle is travelling parallel to the string. \begin{align*} && 3 \tan \alpha &= \frac{b\cos \alpha + Vt \sin \alpha - \frac12 gt^2}{b\sin \alpha - Vt \cos \alpha} \\ &&&= \frac{\frac{V^2}{g}+\frac{4V^2\sin^2\alpha}{g} - \frac{8V^2\sin^2 \alpha}{g}}{\frac{V^2\sin \alpha}{g \cos \alpha} - \frac{4V^2 \sin \alpha \cos \alpha}{g}} \\ &&&= \frac{1 -4\sin^2 \alpha}{\tan \alpha(1 - 4\cos^2 \alpha)} \\ \Leftrightarrow&& 3 \frac{\sin^2 \alpha}{1-\sin^2 \alpha} &= \frac{1- 4 \sin^2 \alpha}{-3+4\sin^2 \alpha} \\ \Leftrightarrow && -9 \sin^2 \alpha + 12 \sin^4 \alpha &= 1 - 5 \sin^2 \alpha + 4 \sin^4 \alpha \\ \Leftrightarrow && 0 &= 1+4 \sin^2 \alpha - 8\sin^4 \alpha \\ \Leftrightarrow && \sin^2 \alpha &= \frac{1 + \sqrt{3}}4 \end{align*} (taking the only positive root)
Examiner's report
— 2018 STEP 3, Question 11
Mean: ~4.5 / 20 (inferred) 20% attempted Inferred 4.5/20 from 'under 5/20' → 5 − 0.5; least successfully attempted question in paper

20% of the candidates attempted this, but it was the least successfully attempted question with a mean score of under 5/20. The vast majority managed only to express correctly. Often, candidates failed to resolve forces correctly, and even those that did frequently abandoned the question at this point. Of those that did continue, roughly half then failed to obtain correct expressions for the initial coordinates of the particle in freefall, which led to incorrect expressions for the general freefall coordinates; candidates that did find these typically progressed well apart from any algebraic errors. Candidates that reached the third part often had a reasonable attempt at it; a significant minority confused displacements and velocities indicating a lack of physical understanding of the question. Although not many attempts were made at the last part, those that understood the conditions did well whilst those that did not could not complete it.

The total entry was a record number, an increase of over 6% on 2017. Only question 1 was attempted by more than 90%, although question 2 was attempted by very nearly 90%. Every question was attempted by a significant number of candidates with even the two least popular questions being attempted by 9%. More than 92% restricted themselves to attempting no more than 7 questions with very few indeed attempting more than 8. As has been normal in the past, apart from a handful of very strong candidates, those attempting six questions scored better than those attempting more than six.

Source: Cambridge STEP 2018 Examiner's Report · 2018-p3.pdf
Rating Information

Difficulty Rating: 1700.0

Difficulty Comparisons: 0

Banger Rating: 1487.9

Banger Comparisons: 1

Show LaTeX source
Problem source
A particle is attached to one end of a light inextensible string of length $b$. The other end of the string is attached to a fixed point $O$.
Initially the particle hangs vertically below $O$.
The particle then receives a horizontal impulse.
The particle moves  in a circular arc with the string taut until the acute angle between the string and the upward vertical is $\alpha$, at which time it becomes slack.
Express $V$, the speed of the particle when the string becomes slack, in terms of $ b$, $g$ and $\alpha$.
  
Show that the string becomes taut again a time $T$ later, where
\[
gT = 4V \sin\alpha     
\,,\]
and that just before this time the trajectory of the  particle makes an angle $\beta $ with the horizontal where $\tan\beta = 3\tan \alpha \,$.
When the string becomes taut, the momentum of the particle in the direction of the string is destroyed. Show that the particle comes instantaneously to rest at this time if and only if 
\[
\sin^2\alpha = \dfrac {1+\sqrt3}4 \,.
\]
Solution source
\begin{center}
    \begin{tikzpicture}[scale=2]
        \coordinate (O) at (0,0);
        \coordinate (X) at (0,2);
        \coordinate (P) at ({2*cos(30)},{2*sin(30)});
        \draw[dashed] (O) circle (2);

        \filldraw (O) circle (1pt);
        \filldraw (P) circle (1pt);
        \draw (O) -- (P);

        \draw[dashed] (X) -- (O);

        \pic [draw, angle radius=0.8cm, "$\alpha$"] {angle = P--O--X};

        \draw[-latex, blue, ultra thick] (P) -- ($(O)!0.5!(P)$) node[left] {$T$};
        \draw[-latex, blue, ultra thick] (P) -- ++(0, -1) node[below] {$mg$};
        
        
    \end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}

\begin{align*}
\text{N2}(\swarrow): &&T +mg \cos \alpha &= m \frac{V^2}{b} \\
\end{align*}
So the string goes slack when $bg\cos \alpha  = V^2 \Rightarrow V = \sqrt{bg \cos \alpha}$.

Once the string goes slack, the particle moves as a projectile. It's initial speed is $V\binom{-\cos \alpha}{\sin \alpha}$ and it's position is $\binom{b\sin \alpha}{b\cos \alpha}$:

\begin{align*}
&& \mathbf{s} &= \binom{b\sin \alpha}{b\cos \alpha}+Vt \binom{-\cos \alpha}{\sin \alpha} + \frac12 gt^2 \binom{0}{-1} \\
&&&= \binom{b\sin \alpha - Vt \cos \alpha}{b\cos \alpha + Vt \sin \alpha - \frac12 gt^2} \\
|\mathbf{s}|^2 = b^2 \Rightarrow && b^2 &= \left ( \binom{b\sin \alpha}{b\cos \alpha}+Vt \binom{-\cos \alpha}{\sin \alpha} + \frac12 gt^2 \binom{0}{-1} \right)^2  \\
&&&= b^2 + V^2t^2+\frac14 g^2 t^4 -gb\cos \alpha t^2-V\sin \alpha gt^3 \\
\Rightarrow && 0 &= V^2t^2 + \frac14 g^2 t^4 - V^2 t^2- V \sin \alpha g t^3 \\
&&&= \frac14 g^2 t^4 - V \sin \alpha gt^3 \\ 
\Rightarrow &&  gT &= 4V \sin \alpha
\end{align*}

The particle will have velocity $\displaystyle \binom{-V \cos \alpha}{V \sin \alpha - 4V \sin \alpha} = \binom{-V \cos \alpha}{-3V \sin \alpha}$ so the angle $\beta$ will satisfy $\tan \beta = 3 \tan \alpha$.

The particle will come to an instantaneous rest if all the momentum is destroyed, ie if the particle is travelling parallel to the string.

\begin{align*}
&& 3 \tan \alpha &= \frac{b\cos \alpha + Vt \sin \alpha - \frac12 gt^2}{b\sin \alpha - Vt \cos \alpha}  \\
&&&= \frac{\frac{V^2}{g}+\frac{4V^2\sin^2\alpha}{g} - \frac{8V^2\sin^2 \alpha}{g}}{\frac{V^2\sin \alpha}{g \cos \alpha} - \frac{4V^2 \sin \alpha \cos \alpha}{g}} \\
&&&= \frac{1 -4\sin^2 \alpha}{\tan \alpha(1 - 4\cos^2 \alpha)} \\
\Leftrightarrow&& 3 \frac{\sin^2 \alpha}{1-\sin^2 \alpha} &= \frac{1- 4 \sin^2 \alpha}{-3+4\sin^2 \alpha} \\
\Leftrightarrow && -9 \sin^2 \alpha + 12 \sin^4 \alpha &= 1 - 5 \sin^2 \alpha + 4 \sin^4 \alpha \\
\Leftrightarrow && 0 &= 1+4 \sin^2 \alpha - 8\sin^4 \alpha \\
\Leftrightarrow && \sin^2 \alpha &= \frac{1 + \sqrt{3}}4
\end{align*}
(taking the only positive root)