2008 Paper 1 Q9

Year: 2008
Paper: 1
Question Number: 9

Course: UFM Mechanics
Section: Circular Motion 2

Difficulty: 1500.0 Banger: 1484.0

Problem

Two identical particles \(P\) and \(Q\), each of mass \(m\), are attached to the ends of a diameter of a light thin circular hoop of radius \(a\). The hoop rolls without slipping along a straight line on a horizontal table with the plane of the hoop vertical. Initially, \(P\) is in contact with the table. At time \(t\), the hoop has rotated through an angle \(\theta\). Write down the position at time \(t\) of \(P\), relative to its starting point, in cartesian coordinates, and determine its speed in terms of \(a\), \(\theta\) and \(\dot\theta\). Show that the total kinetic energy of the two particles is \(2ma^2\dot\theta^2\). Given that the only external forces on the system are gravity and the vertical reaction of the table on the hoop, show that the hoop rolls with constant speed.

Solution

TikZ diagram
We can see that the position of \(O\) is \(\begin{pmatrix} a \theta \\ a \end{pmatrix}\) since the hoop is not slipping. \(P\)'s position relative to \(O\) is \(\begin{pmatrix} -a\sin\theta\\a(1-\cos \theta) \end{pmatrix}\), therefore the position of \(P\) is \(\begin{pmatrix} a(\theta-\sin\theta) \\ a(1-\cos \theta) \end{pmatrix}\). We can now calculate \(\mathbf{v}_P = a \begin{pmatrix} (\dot{\theta}-\dot{\theta}\cos\theta) \\ \dot{\theta}\sin \theta \end{pmatrix} = a \dot{\theta} \begin{pmatrix} (1-\cos\theta) \\ \sin \theta \end{pmatrix}\) We can also see that \begin{align*} && |\mathbf{v}_P|^2 &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l \l 1 - \cos \theta \r^2 + \sin^2 \theta \r \\ && &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 ( 2 - 2\cos \theta) \\ && &= 2a^2\dot{\theta}^2 ( 1 - \cos \theta) \\ && &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 4 \sin^2 \frac{\theta}{2} \\ \Rightarrow |\mathbf{v}_P| &= 2a \dot{\theta} \left | \sin \frac{\theta}2 \right | \end{align*} Not that the position of \(Q\) is \(\begin{pmatrix} a(\theta+\sin\theta) \\ a(1+\cos \theta) \end{pmatrix}\) Therefore \begin{align*} && |\mathbf{v}_Q|^2 &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l \l 1 + \sin \theta \r^2 + \l 1 + \cos \theta \r^2 \r \\ && &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l \l 1 + \sin \theta \r^2 + \cos^2 \theta \r \\ && &= 2a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l 1 + \cos \theta \r \\ \end{align*} Therefore \[ \text{K.E.} = \frac12m|\mathbf{v}_P|^2 + |\mathbf{v}_Q|^2 = \frac12m2a^2 \dot{\theta}^2 (1 - \cos \theta + 1-\cos \theta) = 2ma^2 \dot{\theta}^2\] Since there are no external forces acting conservation of energy tells us that kinetic energy is constant, ie \(4ma^2 \dot{\theta}\ddot{\theta} = 0 \Rightarrow \ddot{\theta} = 0\), ie the hoop is rolling with constant speed.
Examiner's report
— 2008 STEP 1, Question 9
Mean: ~3 / 20 (inferred) Below Average Inferred ~3/20: 'only half of the attempts gained over one mark' and 'only a handful gained over six marks' suggests very low mean around 3

This was an unpopular question and the marks were very disappointing; only half of the attempts gained over one mark out of twenty, and only a handful of candidates gained over six marks. Nonetheless, of the candidates who made a reasonable start, many were capable of drawing a clear diagram of the position of the hoop after it had rolled, but few were able to show how the position after it had rolled related to its initial position. This allowed them to correctly determine the y-coordinate of P, but they became very unstuck when attempting to determine the x-coordinate. The next difficulty encountered was in calculating the components of the velocity of P, as many candidates appeared unable to differentiate a function of θ with respect to t. For the determination of the kinetic energy, several candidates used the expected method. It was also very encouraging to see a number of candidates correctly using the formula total KE = linear KE + rotational KE, and then determining the rotational KE using either moments of inertia or the explicit formula ½mr²θ̇². Finally, a small number of candidates correctly considered forces or energy and deduced that the hoop rolls at constant speed.

There were significantly more candidates attempting this paper this year (an increase of nearly 25%), but many found it to be very difficult and only achieved low scores. The mean score was significantly lower than last year, although a similar number of candidates achieved very high marks. This may be, in part, due to the phenomenon of students in the Lower Sixth (Year 12) being entered for the examination before attempting papers II and III in the Upper Sixth. This is a questionable practice, as while students have enough technical knowledge to answer the STEP I questions at this stage, they often still lack the mathematical maturity to be able to apply their knowledge to these challenging problems. Again, a key difficulty experienced by most candidates was a lack of the algebraic skill required by the questions. At this level, the fluent, confident and correct handling of mathematical symbols (and numbers) is necessary and is expected; many students were simply unable to progress on some questions because they did not know how to handle the algebra. There were of course some excellent scripts, full of logical clarity and perceptive insight. It was also pleasing that one of the applied questions, question 13, attracted a very large number of attempts. However, the examiners were again left with the overall feeling that some candidates had not prepared themselves well for the examination. The use of past papers and other available resources to ensure adequate preparation is strongly recommended. A student's first exposure to STEP questions can be a daunting, demanding experience; it is a shame if that takes place during a public examination on which so much rides.

Source: Cambridge STEP 2008 Examiner's Report · 2008-full.pdf
Rating Information

Difficulty Rating: 1500.0

Difficulty Comparisons: 0

Banger Rating: 1484.0

Banger Comparisons: 1

Show LaTeX source
Problem source
Two identical particles $P$ and $Q$, each of 
mass $m$, are attached to the ends of a diameter
of a light thin circular hoop of radius $a$. 
The hoop rolls without slipping
 along a straight line
on a horizontal table with  the plane of the hoop vertical.
Initially, $P$ is in contact with 
the table. At time $t$, the hoop has rotated through an angle
$\theta$. Write down the position at time $t$ of $P$, relative to its starting
point, in cartesian coordinates, and  determine its speed in
terms
of $a$, $\theta$ and $\dot\theta$. 
Show that the total 
kinetic energy of the two particles is $2ma^2\dot\theta^2$.
Given that the only external forces on the system are gravity
and the vertical reaction of the table on the hoop,
show that the hoop rolls with constant speed.
Solution source
\begin{center}
    
\begin{tikzpicture}
    % Draw the horizontal line
    \draw[thick] (-2,-2) -- (4,-2);

    \coordinate (O) at (0,0);
    \coordinate (P) at (-{sqrt(3)},-1);
    \coordinate (Q) at ({sqrt(3)},1);
    \coordinate (T) at (0,-2);
    
    % Draw the circle
    \draw[thick] (O) circle (2cm);
    
    % Draw the radius to point O
    \draw[thick] (O) -- (P);
    
    % Draw the dashed line
    \draw[dashed] (O) -- (0,-2);
    
    % Add points
    \node[left] at (P) {$P$};
    \node[right] at (Q) {$Q$};
    \node[above] at (O) {$O$};

    \pic [draw, angle radius=0.8cm, "$\theta$"] {angle = P--O--T};
    
    % Add the arrow at the top
    \draw[-{Stealth[length=3mm]}, thick] (-0.5,2.5) -- (0.5,2.5);
\end{tikzpicture}

\end{center}

We can see that the position of $O$ is $\begin{pmatrix} a \theta \\ a \end{pmatrix}$ since the hoop is not slipping. $P$'s position relative to $O$ is $\begin{pmatrix}  -a\sin\theta\\a(1-\cos \theta) \end{pmatrix}$, therefore the position of $P$ is $\begin{pmatrix}  a(\theta-\sin\theta) \\ a(1-\cos \theta) \end{pmatrix}$.

We can now calculate $\mathbf{v}_P = a \begin{pmatrix}  (\dot{\theta}-\dot{\theta}\cos\theta) \\ \dot{\theta}\sin \theta \end{pmatrix} = a \dot{\theta} \begin{pmatrix}  (1-\cos\theta) \\ \sin \theta \end{pmatrix}$

We can also see that 

\begin{align*}
    && |\mathbf{v}_P|^2 &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l \l 1 - \cos \theta \r^2 + \sin^2 \theta \r \\
    && &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 ( 2 - 2\cos \theta) \\
    && &= 2a^2\dot{\theta}^2 ( 1 - \cos \theta) \\
    && &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 4 \sin^2 \frac{\theta}{2} \\
    \Rightarrow |\mathbf{v}_P| &= 2a \dot{\theta} \left | \sin \frac{\theta}2 \right |
\end{align*}

Not that the position of $Q$ is $\begin{pmatrix}  a(\theta+\sin\theta) \\ a(1+\cos \theta) \end{pmatrix}$

Therefore 

\begin{align*}
    && |\mathbf{v}_Q|^2 &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l \l 1 + \sin \theta \r^2 + \l 1 + \cos \theta \r^2 \r \\
    &&  &= a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l \l 1 + \sin \theta \r^2 + \cos^2 \theta  \r \\
    &&  &= 2a^2\dot{\theta}^2 \l 1 + \cos \theta \r \\
\end{align*}

Therefore

\[ \text{K.E.} = \frac12m|\mathbf{v}_P|^2 + |\mathbf{v}_Q|^2 = \frac12m2a^2 \dot{\theta}^2 (1 - \cos \theta + 1-\cos \theta) = 2ma^2 \dot{\theta}^2\]

Since there are no external forces acting conservation of energy tells us that kinetic energy is constant, ie $4ma^2 \dot{\theta}\ddot{\theta} = 0 \Rightarrow \ddot{\theta} = 0$, ie the hoop is rolling with constant speed.