1999 Paper 3 Q7

Year: 1999
Paper: 3
Question Number: 7

Course: UFM Additional Further Pure
Section: Groups

Difficulty: 1680.5 Banger: 1516.0

Problem

Let \(a\) be a non-zero real number and define a binary operation on the set of real numbers by $$ x*y = x+y+axy \,. $$ Show that the operation \(*\) is associative. Show that \((G,*)\) is a group, where \(G\) is the set of all real numbers except for one number which you should identify. Find a subgroup of \((G,*)\) which has exactly 2 elements.

Solution

Claim: \(*\) is associative. Proof: Then \(x*(y*z) = x*(y+z+ayz) = x + (y+z+ayz) + ax(y+z+ayz) = x + y + z + a(yz + xy + zx) + a^2xyz\) and \((x*y)*z = (x+y+axy)*z = (x+y+axy) + z+ a(x+y+axy)z = x + y + z + a(yz + xy + zx) + a^2xyz\) so \(x*(y*z) = (x*y)*z\) and we are done. Let \(G = \mathbb{R} \setminus \{-\frac1{a} \}\) In order to show that \((G, *)\) is a group we need to check:
  1. closure \(x*y = x + y + axy\) is a real number
  2. associativity we have already checked
  3. identity \(x*0 = x + 0 + 0 = x = 0*x\), so \(0\) is an identity
  4. inverses \(x*\left ( \frac{-x}{1+ax} \right ) = x - \frac{x}{1+ax} + ax \frac{-x}{1+ax} = \frac{x +ax^2 - x - ax^2}{1+ax} = 0\) so \(x\) has an identity, assuming \(1+ax \neq 0\) which is true for everything in our set
Consider the set \(\{0, \frac{-2}{a} \}\). Then \(\frac{-2}{a} * \frac{-2}{a} = \frac{-4}{a} + a \frac{4}{a^2} = 0\), so this is a group of order \(2\)
Rating Information

Difficulty Rating: 1680.5

Difficulty Comparisons: 3

Banger Rating: 1516.0

Banger Comparisons: 1

Show LaTeX source
Problem source
Let $a$ be a non-zero real number and define a binary operation
on the set of real numbers by
$$
x*y = x+y+axy \,.
$$
Show that the operation $*$ is associative.
Show that $(G,*)$ is a group, where
$G$ is the set of all real numbers except for one number which you should 
identify.
Find a subgroup of $(G,*)$ which has exactly 2 elements.
Solution source
Claim: $*$ is associative.

Proof:  Then $x*(y*z) = x*(y+z+ayz) = x + (y+z+ayz) + ax(y+z+ayz) = x + y + z + a(yz + xy + zx) + a^2xyz$ and $(x*y)*z = (x+y+axy)*z = (x+y+axy) + z+ a(x+y+axy)z = x + y + z + a(yz + xy + zx) + a^2xyz$ so $x*(y*z) = (x*y)*z$ and we are done.

Let $G = \mathbb{R} \setminus \{-\frac1{a} \}$
In order to show that $(G, *)$ is a group we need to check:

\begin{enumerate}
\item \textbf{closure} $x*y = x + y + axy$ is a real number
\item \textbf{associativity} we have already checked
\item \textbf{identity} $x*0 = x + 0 + 0 = x = 0*x$, so $0$ is an identity
\item \textbf{inverses} $x*\left ( \frac{-x}{1+ax} \right ) = x -  \frac{x}{1+ax} + ax \frac{-x}{1+ax} = \frac{x +ax^2 - x - ax^2}{1+ax} = 0$ so $x$ has an identity, assuming $1+ax \neq 0$ which is true for everything in our set 
\end{enumerate}

Consider the set $\{0, \frac{-2}{a} \}$. Then $\frac{-2}{a} * \frac{-2}{a} = \frac{-4}{a} + a \frac{4}{a^2} = 0$, so this is a group of order $2$